Skip to main content

Every Arsenal player ranked worst to best from the 2-2 draw against Newcastle

The Gunners defence and attack swap from their usual places in this list
ByKenneth Daly
It was a Tyneside return to forget for Bruno Guimaraes
It was a Tyneside return to forget for Bruno Guimaraes | Stu Forster/GettyImages

Every Arsenal player would have got at least 6/10 if this ranking had taken place during the half-time interval.

The 45 minutes that followed it deserves something akin to 3/10 across the board and some corporal punishment in a week-long bootcamp.

This was a textbook case of ‘game of two halves’ and the Gunners will come away from it thankful for the point they held on to, even though they perhaps should have had all three wrapped up after their first-half showing.

Here is a list of every Arsenal player from the 2-2 draw at Newcastle, ranked from worst performer to best.

#16: Mikel Merino

Ranked last solely because he had just five injury-time minutes on the pitch, though the lack of a last-gasp winner like he normally scores was disappointing (JOKING!).

#15: Viktor Gyokeres

In 15th, or joint last, is Viktor Gyokeres, and that is because he too had zero time to make much impact on proceedings. He also ranks in fifteenth as a gentle reprieve from the bashing he normally gets.

#14 Christos Tzolis

Christos Tzolis had a small bit more time to make something happen but the chance never presented itself. If you were being extra critical, perhaps you could bemoan how nothing came from his cross at the end when Arsenal were at a do-or-die juncture and the final whistle loomed, but that might be a little harsh.

He will be more concerned about losing his place to Eberechi Eze and the fact his teammate grabbed a goal.

#13: Myles Lewis-Skelly

Not much to report from MLS which is, in itself, a tad disappointing given how the match hung in the balance when he came on.

But he did not commit any mortal sins during his cameo and is always a good bet for restoring some confidence via his surging carries from midfield, something Arsenal needed as they collapsed under the Toon pressure.

#12: Kepa Arrizabalaga

No one wanted to see Kepa on this list. Judging from what fans saw of him, a longer appearance may have plunged him further down it.

There is no need to be too dramatic of course but the Spaniard did NOT convince anyone with some of his passing from the back. He also had one curious moment near the end when he seemed to go way out of his box to try meet a Newcastle ball over the top before aborting the plan while standing in no man’s land.

I, for one, am glad that Newcastle did not get a chance to test his saving ability or truly surround him at a set-piece.

#11: Bruno Guimaraes

On to the first team now and another name that no Arsenal fan would want to see rank this far down the list.

Bruno Guimaraes has flattered to deceive since his arrival but this was supposed to be his chance to announce himself, back on Tyneside after an acrimonious summer exit and an opportunity to get one over his former employers.

He failed to take it.

Largely anonymous in possession, ineffective out of it and came out second best in every duel in the midfield. Any attempt to break the lines fell flat and he at least bears some responsibility for the way Newcastle steamrolled through the middle in the second half.

Everyone expected so much more from him this season but MLS has surpassed him and has a strong case to start ahead of Bruno next week.

#10: Jurrien Timber

So unlike Jurrien Timber.

Normally so reliable and assured either going forward or covering at the back, the Dutchman looked out of sorts here. He gave the ball away on a few occasions and was hopelessly beaten for pace when Newcastle hit on the counter.

It was also evident for the Harvey Barnes goal, but he could not have expected that Martin Odegaard would cough up possession so carelessly, so he can perhaps be forgiven for his failure to stop Barnes from scoring.

Timber averages one bad game every six months. Fans will have few issues with writing this one off as a bad night which he will bounce back from.

#9: Declan Rice

He is marked down because he was part of an Arsenal midfield which went AWOL as Newcastle came roaring back into the contest.

Rice also loses marks for his close brushes with the law. First, he got booked for a cynical trip, before going close to conceding a penalty (and a red card) with an attempted pull back on Lewis Miley as he bore down on goal.

And ANOTHER close brush when he dived in on Tino Livramento. It could easily have seen him sent off, though doubts about whether or not there was any contact at all mean he deserved to not get dismissed for that challenge.

Those disciplinary flashpoints were the only things that stood out. In terms of the football, Rice had little impact.

#8: Ezri Konsa

The world is upside down!

Number eight goes to another man who normally ranks among the standout players, with Ezri Konsa having his weakest game in an Arsenal shirt.

He was one of many in red and white to catch the sloppiness bug during the half-time team talk and it allowed Newcastle to build up a head of steam, one which reached its peak during the corner that Konsa and co. defended so poorly to give the home team the lead.

This was not the Konsa fans have come to know and love, and it remains to be seen how long he lasts in the team – not because of a bad performance here, but rather because William Saliba is ready for his first-team return!

#7: Gabriel

Like the others, Gabriel was well off the pace.

Maybe he can be excused on the grounds that he seemed to be nursing a hip problem in the first half which might have impacted his mobility.

It certainly affected his balance anyway, because it was he who clumsily fell on top of his own ‘keeper to take David Raya out of the equation and leave Malick Thiaw with a tap-in to put Newcastle into an unlikely lead.

Perhaps the entire defence should just forget this match ever happened and put together a plan for keeping Erling Haaland quiet next week.

#6: Riccardo Calafiori

The least comical member of the backline on Tyneside – a badge that he should wear with no pride whatsoever.

Calafiori looked assured in a defensive sense, or like an absolute beast compared to his teammates, but disappointed a tad going forward. He still popped up in all sorts of random positions but failed to make the most of it, especially when he took a poor touch in the first half when played in and a first-time shot might have been the better option.

Not much to report from him beyond that, which is good going for an Arsenal defender considering the bizarre circumstances.

#5: Martin Odegaard

He might have ranked lower if there was not such stiff competition among the poorer performers in red and white.

Odegaard helped Arsenal establish their stranglehold in the first half and produced a piece of magic to tee up Calafiori for the chance mentioned above.

Yet he undid that good work with the horrible sliced clearance that allowed William Osula to hit on the break, setting up Harvey Barnes for an equaliser which lit the touchpaper for a Newcastle revival which the Gunners barely survived.

Another strike goes against him for the strange decision to cut back to Madueke instead of Calafiori during a counter attack in the dying embers, with Madueke then deemed offside while the Italian had sight of goal.

#4: David Raya

Similar to Calafiori, David Raya stands out for his ‘normalness’ amidst a chaotic and calamitous away performance.

There was nothing he could do about the first goal but the second might be somewhat attributable to him, seeing how he is typically excellent at diffusing set-piece situations. Perhaps one can excuse him on the grounds that Newcastle challenged him well and that he was not helped by the frame of Gabriel falling backwards at the same time.

Raya was never really tested in open play and he made no mistakes. The lack of talking points is very welcome.

#3: Eberechi Eze

Does his goal mask an otherwise ‘meh’ display?

Maybe so, but it was so well taken – and there are so few other positives to discuss – that one should let the goal mask it. Arsenal are generally timid in front of goal, which made Eze’s decision to smash it first time all the more satisfying to watch.

Further credit for winning a free kick in a good position at the end of the first half, although his pass selection and execution left much to be desired at times.

#2: Kai Havertz

Like Eze, his involvement in the one bit of Arsenal quality from this match earns Kai Havertz this high ranking.

He did brilliantly to nip in ahead of Lewis Hall to get possession initially, but that effort was surpassed by the delightful ball through to Eze which allowed him to run onto it and shoot first time before the goalkeeper had time to even think.

Havertz had little joy in the remainder of the match, his biggest positive being the fortune which saw his attempted headed clearance clip the top of Kepa’s crossbar rather than drop painfully beneath it for a late Newcastle winner.

#1: Noni Madueke

Noni Madueke was the sole Arsenal player who had a decent 90 minutes overall and did not confine his good moments to a goal.

In fact, his goal was one of the weaker aspects of his performance; it was a poor shot that Hornicek should have saved. But score it he did, and it was a cherry on top of a strong individual showing that made him the Gunners’ most dangerous forward.

As mentioned in the positives/negatives piece, he was still a bit wasteful in an attacking sense, but it does not entirely take away from a lively display. Get those final details right more often and he could have a hell of a campaign.

Add us as a preferred source on Google